India’s securities regulator, the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI), has introduced significant regulatory changes aimed at curbing speculative trading in the equity derivatives market. These new rules are primarily designed to protect retail investors, whose increasing participation in derivative trading has fueled unprecedented growth in this segment.
The new regulations include limits on short-term speculative trades, such as capping the number of index option contracts with weekly expiries. These changes, published on SEBI’s website on Tuesday, are part of the regulator’s broader goal to reduce risk in the derivatives market while ensuring that household savings are channeled toward more productive uses.
This move comes in response to the explosive rise in India’s equity derivatives market, which has surged 40-fold since 2019, with trading volume reaching a record $6 trillion in February—surpassing the size of the country’s economy. The dramatic growth in derivatives trading, particularly driven by retail investors, has led to concerns about market volatility and speculative behavior. The hope is that the new measures will cool a market that has seen a significant influx of small investors, many of whom may lack the experience to navigate these complex products.
Brokerage firms, whose revenues have benefitted from the boom in derivatives trading, particularly from retail investors, may see a dip in their earnings as these new rules come into effect. The measures are expected to reduce speculative activity, with some market analysts predicting a notable decline in trading volumes.
Impact on Market Players
“We’re factoring in a potential 30% decline in overall option volumes,” said Abhilash Pagaria, quantitative strategist at Nuvama Wealth Management. “This regulatory overhang has been anticipated, and most estimates are already building in this reduction.”
In addition to retail investors, the new regulations may also affect high-frequency trading firms that have gained a foothold in India’s $5 trillion stock market. Companies such as Optiver BV, Citadel Securities LLP, and Jump Trading have expanded their presence in India’s derivatives market in recent years. These firms, leveraging advanced algorithms, have capitalized on the volatility in futures and options markets, generating significant profits. According to SEBI, foreign investors and proprietary trading desks earned $7 billion in gross profits from these products in the last financial year.
The regulatory overhaul is the most comprehensive market intervention since the onset of the Covid-19 pandemic when SEBI implemented measures to curb excessive short-selling. The changes will be implemented in phases, starting on November 20, with full implementation by April 1, 2024.
One of the most significant aspects of the new regulations is the limitation on weekly options, which SEBI has blamed for increased volatility and hyperactive trading, particularly on expiry days. Weekly options, introduced by the National Stock Exchange of India Ltd. in 2019, have contributed to excessive speculative trading, prompting the regulator to act.
“We are now reaching a more mature stage in the market where the regulator has recognized that introducing weekly products may have been a mistake. These changes will stabilize the derivatives market and support a more sustainable, long-term structure,” said Tejas Shah, head of derivatives at Equirus Securities Pvt.
Protecting Retail Investors
The new rules are also focused on protecting retail traders, who have been highly active in derivatives trading. A recent SEBI study revealed that 93% of retail investors in this segment lost money over a three-year period ending in March 2023. Retail traders currently account for over one-third of the options market, which has traditionally been dominated by high-frequency traders.
In 2023 alone, local investors traded 85 billion derivative contracts, making India the largest market for these products globally. India’s derivatives market garnered international attention earlier this year when US-based Jane Street Group disclosed that its trading strategy in the country generated $1 billion in profits in 2022.
With the new rules in place, SEBI hopes to temper speculative trading and bring greater stability to India’s rapidly growing derivatives market. Although trading volumes have cooled slightly since the February record of $6 trillion, the long-term effects of these measures on the market and its participants remain to be seen.
Analysis and Market Opportunity:
These new regulations present a double-edged sword for market participants. On one hand, brokers and high-frequency traders might experience reduced volumes and profits in the short term. On the other hand, a more stable derivatives market could bring long-term benefits by attracting institutional investors and enhancing market transparency.
The decline in speculative activity might also lead to better market pricing, allowing savvy investors to capitalize on more predictable trends. With SEBI aiming to direct household savings toward more productive uses, sectors such as infrastructure, manufacturing, and technology could see inflows from investors who previously sought gains in the derivatives market.
Leave feedback about this